I’ve lost count of how many times people have quoted Genesis at me, as if saying “In the beginning…” is all the proof you need. Truth is, these religious stories didn’t materialize out of nowhere. They’re the products of centuries of storytelling, rumor-spreading, and cultural borrowing that would make even the best modern plagiarists blush.

If you think that’s harsh, just look at the countless parallels between the biblical Flood and Mesopotamian tales like the Enuma Elish and the Epic of Gilgamesh. These older myths often show up in the Bible with just a little editing to fit a new theological context. Imagine a cosmic game of telephone spanning entire empires, each city-state adding its spin to a basic myth about creation or calamity.

Then there’s the issue of motivations. Writers (or, more accurately, scribes) in ancient Judah or Babylonia had agendas — political, religious, or otherwise. They didn’t sit around telling purely factual accounts; they told stories that solidified a national identity or justified a ruling class. Think of them as the propaganda writers of their day, shifting details to serve a grander purpose.

And that’s before we even mention the chaos of translation. From ancient Hebrew and Aramaic to Greek and then Latin, and finally into the languages we know today, each scribe or translator took liberties. Even a single mistranslated word, like “alma” to “parthenos” (young woman to virgin), can launch a whole new doctrine. You’d be amazed how much subtle word-swapping can reshape a theological worldview, all without the average believer noticing.

Let’s not forget the historical context. Consider the story of Moses leading an enslaved people out of Egypt. Modern archaeology? Crickets. No sign of millions leaving behind pottery fragments or footprints. The walls of Jericho that supposedly came tumbling down? They had already collapsed centuries before the Israelites supposedly arrived. These narratives function more as cultural legends or identity markers than as bulletproof histories.

People then ask, “What about the miracles? Isn’t that proof it’s all divinely backed?” Well, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Whether it’s the Red Sea parting on command or Jesus walking on water, none of these wonders show up in contemporary records from neighboring civilizations. If a fisherman in ancient Rome wrote about gossip in far-off provinces, you’d think something as big as a sea splitting might have made it into the diaries, right?

But the Bible’s biggest challenge might be its own evolution. Ever heard of the Documentary Hypothesis? Four major sources contributed to the Pentateuch, each with its style and biases. These sources were then knitted together like a patchwork quilt, leading to the famous double creation story in Genesis or the conflicting instructions in Deuteronomy. You don’t need to be a scholar to see that if one book can’t even keep its own details straight, it’s a shaky candidate for undisputed truth.

By the time the Church got around to deciding which books to include in the canon, centuries had passed. Early “heretical” or “apocryphal” works were discarded, and official versions got rubber-stamped. The Catholic Church kept a near-monopoly on how the Bible was translated and read, especially during the Middle Ages, so only one “authorized” narrative survived in public consciousness. When a single institution controls the editing pen, the result can hardly be called unbiased.

Then there’s modern science. Genesis claims everything popped up in six days a few thousand years ago, which contradicts pretty much everything geology and biology have observed. Evolutionary theory? Let’s just say Adam and Eve being molded from dust doesn’t mesh with 200,000-year-old Homo sapiens fossils. Throw in DNA research, radiometric dating, and cosmic background radiation, and it’s game over for literal six-day creation.

And don’t get me started on Noah’s Ark. Two (or seven) of each creature crammed into a wooden boat, floating over a planet-wide ocean? Beyond the comedic logistical nightmare, there’s zero geological evidence for a global flood. Not a single sediment layer suggests the Earth was submerged. Unless the ark had a trunk full of Poké Balls to store all those animals, it’s safe to call it an overblown allegory.

Over time, people are catching on. Church attendance in many Western countries has dropped, and more folks identify as “nones,” meaning they have no religious affiliation. It’s not that they despise spirituality; they just find these ancient texts wanting when stacked against modern knowledge. If someone insists the entire planet was drowned except for one boat crew, a person who’s read a bit of geology or biology tends to walk away unimpressed.

Which isn’t to say there’s zero value in the Bible. It’s full of poetry, moral lessons, and cultural insights that shaped much of Western civilization. But as a historical or scientific record? The cracks are too deep to ignore. And if you dig enough, you’ll find those cracks were there from the get-go, held together by centuries of tradition and institutional power rather than undeniable facts.

Ultimately, seeing the Bible as a fascinating patchwork of stories, myths, and occasional nuggets of wisdom might be more honest — and more rewarding — than trying to pretend it’s a flawless eyewitness account from the dawn of time. As new discoveries challenge biblical claims, maybe the best approach is to let these ancient writings stand as a testament to humanity’s evolving understanding, rather than an unshakable pillar of absolute truth.

Because in the end, that’s what the Bible really is: a living collage of ideas, retold and reworked to fit eras long past. And if we can appreciate it on those terms — cultural artifact rather than cosmic fact — then maybe we can finally put the question of its scientific or historical reliability to rest and explore its stories as the intriguing, if flawed, reflections of the humans who penned them.

Follow me on social media

Facebook: www.facebook.com/xhannyahofficial/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/xhannyah/
Threads: https://www.threads.net/@xhannyah
Discord: https://discord.gg/GDfX5BFGye